Reynold's Pasty Shop

Nestled in the heart of Milwaukee, Reynold's Pasty Shop serves up a hearty slice of tradition with every fresh-baked pasty. Rooted in the comforting flavors of Upper Peninsula Michigan, this beloved eatery specializes in crafting golden, flaky pasties filled with a savory blend that instantly awakens the senses. Whether you’re craving the classic Fresh N’ Hot Pasty with an optional rich Beef Gravy Add-On or prefer to enjoy your meal at your leisure with a Par-Baked Pasty or even a Frozen Pasty to take home, Reynold’s offers a range that satisfies every appetite and schedule.

The moment you bite into one of their hand-crafted pasties, the warm, buttery crust gives way to a comforting embrace of seasoned meat and vegetables, reminiscent of a home-cooked feast. Popular add-ons like Hot Cheese and tangy Sour Cream elevate the richness, while the optional Jalapeno Peppers add a lively kick for those who like a bit of heat. And no meal here feels complete without a sweet finish—indulge in a slice of their decadently nutty Pecan Pie or a flaky Apple Turnover, both perfect companions to their savory staples.

Reynold's Pasty Shop is more than just a spot to grab a quick bite; it’s a culinary refuge for anyone yearning for genuine, soul-satisfying flavors. Customers rave about the lightning-fast service paired with warm, friendly smiles that make each visit feel personal and welcoming. As one fan puts it, it’s “the best restaurant in all of Milwaukee,” where every bite tastes like a piece of paradise.

Whether you’re a pasty aficionado familiar with the Upper Peninsula’s iconic dish or a newcomer eager to explore, Reynold’s delivers authentic comfort food that’s both nostalgic and invigorating. From locals to visitors traveling hundreds of miles for a taste, this shop stands out as a true gem, blending tradition, quality, and heart in every product.

Experience the irresistible charm and bold flavors of Reynold’s Pasty Shop, where each pasty promises a savory journey that leaves you craving more—truly a Milwaukee treasure worth savoring.