Reynold's Pasty Shop Menu

Reynold's Pasty Shop serves up Milwaukee’s finest traditional pasties, capturing the rich heritage of the Upper Peninsula. Their Fresh N' Hot Pasty, priced at $5.90, is a standout—flaky, savory, and piping hot, embodying comfort food at its best. For those wanting to customize, add-ons like hot cheese, beef gravy, or sour cream elevate the flavors with creamy, tangy, and hearty notes. The option of par-baked or frozen pasties offers convenience without sacrificing that authentic taste. Beyond pasties, the menu includes classic desserts like pecan pie slices and apple turnovers, adding a sweet finish to the meal. The careful balance of freshness and tradition shines through each dish, making it a must-visit for any pasty lover. Customer praise highlights the fast service, quality ingredients, and exceptional value, which all contribute to the genuine, homey experience Reynold’s delivers every time.